First of all, I’d like to wish Happy Independence Day to all my readers. Today was a day of a national reconciliation for me (like many other of my compatriots). Yet, the national experience of today has been different than previous ones, towards the worse. Although I am more aware about my country today than I was yesterday, I feel no prouder of my country. The feeling I have today is of disappointment (and not disillusionment, mind you). I still believe in my country and its potential to be the world’s finest, but today, I must criticize it for the state of affairs that pervade it.
Incidentally, I watched the movie Peepli Live today, and it left me disappointed and depressed. I already know the current state of India, how it is soiled in corruption, red tape and dirty politics – what I didn’t learn is how can I make a difference… what I, the Common Man of India can do today to ensure a more prosperous tomorrow. The movie had plenty of Masala, its fair share of Profanities (were they trying to say its commonplace in India? – I know that too), lots of humour, pathetic and sorry humour that should make every Indian cry in shame about his country and vow to make a difference. But no, the effect it had on my fellow countrymen was… frantic laughter. Ironic is an understatement for the movie; Tragic is a more apt word. Tragic not because the “big-shot” director Aamir Khan decided to make a film exposing the true face of “Real India, Poor India” (yet again). No, tragic because he made no attempt at encouraging his countrymen to take some action in fixing it. He did a better job encouraging (urging) the youth to take up violent measures, through another of his blockbusters, Rang
It’s as simple as this – movies are made to entertain, with a side motive being educating and uplifting the masses. But movies like Peepli Live, that take India’s case apart, and that too in a cheeky mockery, must be banned from public broadcast, unless they feature some relief, some take-home for the audience, that they might use as a starting point in overcoming the same painful issues that they have now made a laughing stock of. Undoubtedly, movies direct wandering minds (youths, our country’s future), inspire and induce action – and certainly any efforts to exacerbate our country’s predicament, through the media or otherwise, must be curbed.
I also attended the #
interestng observations, ojas. i'll be writing tomorrow.
ReplyDeleteIs the point of art to direct your actions to "do the right thing" or merely enlighten, touch and drive you into finding your own voice, opinion and way of life? Personally, I don't get why the task of "guiding people" is Aamir Khan's (or for that matter anybody's) responsibility.
ReplyDeleteIt is true that media personalities have a broader and deeper impact on the masses - as I can see Gul Panag's presence was cited as quite the endorsement even for something as driven as a conference of bloggers - people with strong, eloquent voices with the capacity to think for themselves and share their thoughts.
Also, what Aamir Khan thinks of himself (as a self proclaimed activist or catalyst of change) should ideally not be a matter of debate - because in his own way he is doing his bit to create awareness about the topics he touches - in addition to his "real, human" (if you will) motives of making sure the movie does well at the box office and his art crosses the boundary from being ponderous to actually raking in some commercial success too - which means more people watch it and in turn, are at least exposed to the issue at hand.
I have no conclusion. I enjoyed your blog entry- it made me think. And I think that is the _point_ after all, isn't it?
I wud disagree with you dude. The movie is very well made and highlights the issue faced by the country today. Dont u think the solution should come from young people like us instead of asking for solution from a movie. Grow up mate!
ReplyDeleteHellllo...are you trying to shoot the messenger? India is suffering due to bad inertia and degeneration from centuries and millenia of the past. Aamir is one of the few truly enlightened people in the movie industry who knows that best way to connect people with issues is to provide an engaging entertainment. It is OK to be scathing about the technical aspects of this movie but please don't trash Aamir's intentions.
ReplyDeleteI would partially agree with you. But putting a tragedy in humorous way is an art. There is no vulgarity in the movie. It is sort of exaggeration of a farmer’s state of mind who is too frustrated to do anything till suicide, governments fight within themselves or do anything for their votes while Media fights selfishly for their TRP. These all are ugly truths of ‘Independent Democratic’ India. If the viewer is a true Indian, by soul, he should think what best he can do for next Natha or Buthia.
ReplyDeleteThank you all for your comments. It is truly heartening to see individual thought emerge.
ReplyDeleteThere is no doubt that the movie has given us plenty of food for thought. And it is undeniable that this movie has given us a talking point, a platform for youths like you and me to discuss the fate of our country, with the hope of arriving at a constructive plan.
Yet, I feel Aamir Khan, with his stature and influencing power, could have injected some more positivity and purpose in his movie. The majority of our country, although more aware of the nation's status quo, is still having a good laugh about the characters and dialogues in the movie, and now has a general sense of frivolity towards the issue. This has probably buried the (very implicit) message in the back of their minds.
What our nation needs today, especially in these tender issues, is a sense of direction, from the agents that have the power to direct. Our country (like every other) moves to media's tune. Although it is no legal, political, economic or social binding, I believe it is the movie makers' moral duty to move the masses to the greater good, than leave them with an image of Natha sitting thoughtless at a construction site. Maybe there could be a little twist in the tale, a little moment of inspiration, a small direct message - that would want the aam junta to want to make a difference. In that respect, I found Well Done Abba a more rewarding watch.. it gave hope at the end of the desolation.
It is true that it is the youth's role to inspire change. But Aamir IS our youth icon after all. What if he spent 10% of the movie's budget in setting up an organization to educate the rural poor, or a media body promoting ethics and clean politics. I feel that would have gone a longer way in inspiring us youth (who frankly do need a push)
In Aamir Khan's defense, "I am an entertainer, not a social activist," he recently quoted. In which case I believe he would be better off entertaining us about something that is not one of India's burning problems.
Seriously, I've lost any sense of social activism from Aamir Khan. Why is it that people start hyperventilating as soon as you mention his name ? What has he done ? Made some movies that did well ? Well, that only padded his pocket. What has he actually done for the society ? Donations to charitable causes - none. Social blogs - none. Youth movements - none. Yes, he makes good movies. But that's about it. And even that is debatable, what with the Ghajinis and the 3 idiots (yes, I hate the movie). Why do we still feel the need to look for social activism in this particular man's movies ?
ReplyDeleteWas it a movie ? OR may be more an art film ?
ReplyDelete& I don't think it raised farmer's voice or was based on farmer suicide. It was a joke ?
The movie make fun of farmers. The director could show some issues seriously but there was all humor. No sensitivity @ all.
I didn't like movie at all. It just brand Aamir that took movie on top otherwise it is FLOP PF THE YEAR. I won't watch it even for FREE.
Anyone says that abusing words are acceptable just go to see some C grade movies you can see all there.
Just imagine about the whole family sitting just near to me.. The kids & their mom dad all came in the faith of the name of Aamir khan & it put them in Awkward situation. They are not likely to go again for aamir's movie.
All these are just cheap ways of money making by selling poor india, such movies should be banned.
I hate this bloody f****** Aamir khan now.
I found the presentation of the movie grossly misplaced. What was intended to be a satirical humour turned out to be a big self-depreciating joke and only fools who cannot think themselves would find most of the events going on in the movie truly laughable.AS IF WE DIDN'T KNOW ALREADY! It was a shame to hear the revolting comments lashed out by my fellow audience at the poor man's plight while sitting in the comfort chair of a multiplex. Maybe the director should have chosen the theme with the aim of providing a solution...
ReplyDeleteJust because he is person whose words will be paid heed to by the youth doesnt mean he has a duty,moral or otherwise, to educate them.As you said you werent even aware of such scenarios existing in our glorious country and now you are aware of them, I guess the movie served its purpose.
ReplyDeleteHow do you reach out to the regular multiplex going audience...not by a socially-inspiring-art-movie.The person who actually wants to sort out our problems can easily perceive the message and the inspiration from this Masala movie itself.And yes totally agree with Maitri.
Now let me ask you something.Now that you KNOW that there is something to be done,what are you going to do apart from bragging about the number of comments your blog is getting.
As D Prasad said "Dont u think the solution should come from young people like us instead of asking for solution from a movie. Grow up mate!"
For a different perspective :
ReplyDeletehttp://dheerajtripathi.blogspot.com/2010/08/of-realities-and-entertainment-peepli.html
without knowing about your country dont speak or write. If you want to change the county go and live in a village for a year.
ReplyDeleteNever tell you will be changing the country. F__ku.
Dear anonymous. A strong opinion but no face? Stand up and speak out!
ReplyDeleteAs a matter of fact I have lived in the villages of Rajasthan a couple of months, and this is exactly the sort of thing that happens there. My point, as before, being, the predicament could have been portrayed in a more serious manner. Maybe it was after all satire, and maybe it did intend to serve as an eye opener. But from what I've gathered of people discussing the movie, it was good light hearted entertainment. Do you really want to trivialize the matter by joking about it?
Henceforth, please reveal your identity before commenting, or your comment will be deleted.
Dear Aniket I am shocked to hear that you only knew about our poor India only after watching peepli live. May be except you everyone knows about villages.. farmers issue.. corruption etc. The director is failed to live up to the subject of the movie. She really did not feel for the farmers but she made fun of farmers issue & even what is shown in the movie is not possible in reality @ all that a farmer announce to suicide cause of poverty & no one come to help him immediately. If this would have been in reality there would be a long queue of politicians & celebrity @ natha's home. Remember Narendar Modi who sent a big check to hemant karkare, a police officer of maharashtra martyr of mumbai bomb blast.
ReplyDeleteSo the movie is totally a time waste with no real thought.. May be more than reality.
@mayur
ReplyDelete1) I knew about the issue before even Amir thought of making the movie because my grandfather IS a farmer and still lives in a small village in U.P.
2) I have not seen the movie.
so you have not even watched the movie & discussing about it here...! huh..
ReplyDeleteThanks.! for post a movie. They are the one of the best movie of the bollywood.
ReplyDelete